The end of an era: MIXED.de and the devastating consequences of Google's AI revolution

Virtual reality meets reality: Why MIXED had to close

The closure of the German-language VR and AR magazine MIXED.de and its English version MIXED-NEWS.com on June 1, 2025, marks a turning point in the history of digital journalism. After ten years of successful reporting on virtual and augmented reality, the magazine became the first prominent victim of Google's radical AI transformation of internet search. MIXED's fate exemplifies how the integration of artificial intelligence into Google's search engine poses an existential threat to small and independent online magazines and shakes the foundations of the open internet. The drastic drops in traffic experienced by MIXED are not an isolated incident—they reflect an industry-wide crisis triggered by Google's AI Overviews and new AI features, jeopardizing the economic survival of thousands of publishers.

The closure of MIXED.de as a symptom of a larger crisis

MIXED.de, once the largest German-language knowledge resource for virtual and augmented reality with over 17,000 articles, had to cease operations after ten years of successful reporting. The decision was announced on June 1, 2025, with authors Josef and Tomislav continuing their work at heise online. The demise of MIXED is not the result of poor quality or a lack of readership, but rather a direct consequence of Google's sweeping changes to its search engine.

MIXED's development unfolded in several disastrous phases. Just a year and a half ago, the website was well-positioned, with a rapidly growing English-language counterpart that benefited from the Metaverse hype triggered by Meta. The turning point came immediately after Meta Connect 2023, when Google's search algorithm demoted the English site, and traffic plummeted by an estimated 90 percent overnight. Articles that had previously garnered four- or five-figure page views suddenly received only a few hundred.

This dramatic development was not an isolated incident, but affected thousands of other small and medium-sized online magazines and blogs whose livelihoods were destroyed overnight. Author Tomislav describes the past nine months as “psychologically very stressful,” as traffic had become “unpredictable” and felt like “an emotional roller coaster.” These personal accounts highlight the human cost of Google’s algorithmic decisions.

The economic impact was devastating. While MIXED had a few hundred Plus subscribers, their number was declining and never sufficient to even cover the salary of a single editor. As an online magazine, MIXED was therefore dependent on Google advertising revenue, which virtually disappeared due to the algorithm changes. This led to a vicious cycle: declining revenue resulted in fewer resources, leading to a greater focus on topics with high click potential, sensationalist headlines, and a loss of content diversity.

Google's AI transformation and the introduction of AI Overviews

Over the past two years, Google has initiated a radical transformation of its search engine based on the integration of artificial intelligence. In May 2024, at its I/O developer conference, Google introduced "AI Overviews," which were initially rolled out in the US and later in Germany. These AI summaries appear above the traditional list of links to further websites and are designed to offer a quick and convenient way to obtain information without having to click through multiple websites.

According to Google, the “AI-powered overview” is displayed whenever “our systems determine it’s the most helpful answer.” Initial analyses indicate this occurs in approximately one out of every five Google searches. Google reports that the launch of “AI-powered overview” has become one of the most successful search product launches of the last decade, with a usage increase of over 10 percent in major markets such as the US and India.

In May 2025, Google announced further revolutionary changes, including the new “AI Mode,” which can answer more complex queries similar to chat tools like ChatGPT or Perplexity. CEO Sundar Pichai spoke of a “complete redesign of web search.” The AI ​​Mode uses a method in which a question is broken down into individual subtopics and a multitude of search queries are executed simultaneously. Technically, the AI ​​Mode is based on a customized version of Gemini 2.5.

Google is taking an enormous risk with this AI offensive, as the company primarily earns its money through advertising related to web searches. Extensive changes to its core product could severely damage its business model. Nevertheless, the search giant seems to have no alternative, as "Google is under massive pressure," explains Georg Zöller, co-founder of the Centre for AI Leadership in Singapore.

Suitable for:

• Google AI Overviews: Global expansion and new monetization strategies are transforming the search landscape

Massive traffic drops for online publishers

The impact of Google's AI transformation on online publishers is devastating. An exclusive report by the US news agency Bloomberg, based on interviews with 25 publishers and data from the analytics firm Similarweb, reveals the extent of the crisis. Small and medium-sized websites are experiencing an unprecedented drop in traffic, with some sites losing 70 percent of their traffic, and some even more.

A particularly dramatic example is Debra Corbeil and Dave Bouskill from Canada, who have run the travel blog The Planet D since 2008. In 2024, their traffic plummeted by 90 percent, forcing them to lay off staff and subsequently shut down the business. What they found particularly painful was that Google's AI had even adopted their Canadian slang, without any compensation or recognition. "I feel betrayed," says Bouskill, and Corbeil confirms: "Betrayed – that's the word.".

Mike Hardaker, the operator of the outdoor news portal Mountain Weekly News, generated $250,000 in revenue in 2023, but now relies on food aid. These personal stories illustrate the dramatic consequences of Google's algorithmic decisions for real people and their livelihoods.

Niche areas like travel, cooking, and DIY are particularly hard hit. This is confirmed by data from Similarweb in New York City, with the travel category being the hardest hit – precisely when Google rolled out a significant number of AI features for it. Publisher Gisele Navarro of the air purifier blog Housefresh reports that her content now appears more frequently in Google's AI Overviews, but users aren't clicking on her website.

Some platforms, such as the New York-based media company Raptive, estimate that up to 25 percent of total website traffic will be lost to AI Overviews in the long term. And that's a conservative estimate. Google is currently testing further features like recipe summaries directly in search results, which could mean a loss of up to 50 percent of traffic for food blogs.

Benefit from Xpert.Digital's extensive, fivefold expertise in a comprehensive service package | R&D, XR, PR & Digital Visibility Optimization - Image: Xpert.Digital

Xpert.Digital has in-depth knowledge of various industries. This allows us to develop tailor-made strategies that are tailored precisely to the requirements and challenges of your specific market segment. By continually analyzing market trends and following industry developments, we can act with foresight and offer innovative solutions. Through the combination of experience and knowledge, we generate added value and give our customers a decisive competitive advantage.

More about it here:

• Use the 5x expertise of Xpert.Digital in one package - starting at just €500/month

Google's attempts at justification and the industry's reaction

In October 2024, Google invited around 20 website operators to Mountain View, California, to discuss the impact of its increasing use of AI. The participants unanimously reported that Google apologized, praised their content, and then stated that there was no hope for improvement. Search was simply different now. This stance illustrates that Google accepts the collateral damage of its AI transformation as inevitable.

Google emphasizes its intention to prioritize content from experienced and knowledgeable users. However, an analysis by Brightedge reveals that the biggest beneficiaries of AI Overviews are large sites like TripAdvisor, Wikipedia, and Google's own YouTube. Many small publishers report losing out in the visibility battle against forums like Reddit and Quora—or against AI-generated spam sites that are virtually indistinguishable from their real-world counterparts.

The media industry is reacting with increasing vehemence to these developments. The News/Media Alliance (NMA), a lobbying organization with nearly 2,000 members from the media sector in the US and Canada, complains: “Now Google is simply taking content by force and using it without paying for it. That is the definition of theft.” Danielle Coffey, president of the News/Media Alliance, stated that links in Google search results were “the last positive attribute” of search engines “that brought publishers traffic and revenue.”.

The NMA criticizes in particular that publishers can only completely exclude their content from the training of AI models, in which case it no longer appears in search results at all. This is an inadequate solution, especially for smaller media companies. The organization is calling on the US Department of Justice to take action to break the company's dominance on the internet.

Suitable for:

• Google's AI search mode under fire: publisher speak of “theft” and fear for their existence

Core Updates as an additional burden factor

Besides AI features, Google's regular core updates also play a crucial role in the traffic declines. These updates are designed to improve the quality of search results but can significantly impact website rankings. Google released several major core updates in 2024 alone, including the November 2024 Core Update and the December 2024 Core Update.

The November 2023 Core Update brought profound changes to how Google evaluates AI-generated content. This update emphasized the importance of high-quality, relevant content for users, regardless of whether it was created by humans or AI. At the same time, it led to significant ranking shifts, negatively impacting many smaller websites.

A particularly problematic aspect is that Google makes thousands of updates per year but only publicly announces a few of the notable ones. This lack of transparency makes it difficult for website operators to understand why their rankings suddenly plummet. Pandu Nayak, Google's Vice President of Search, confirmed to the US Department of Justice that Google uses different ranking signals, including traditional signals and those generated using machine learning.

For Navboost, a system for measuring user interactions, Google only uses data from the last 13 months. This means that the weighting of various factors can constantly change, leading to unpredictable traffic fluctuations. This systemic uncertainty makes it virtually impossible for small publishers like MIXED to plan and survive in the long term.

Suitable for:

• The Google Algorithm Updates of 2024: An In-Depth Look and What They Mean for Search Engine Optimization (SEO)

The transformation of the search market and new competitive dynamics

Google's AI offensive is also a reaction to the growing competitive pressure from AI chatbots like ChatGPT, Claude, and Perplexity AI. More and more users are turning to these chatbots in addition to search engines, which threatens Google's core business. Google CEO Sundar Pichai is under particularly intense pressure to justify the company's actions, as search generates by far the largest share of its profits.

The introduction of AI Mode is Google's attempt to defend its market leadership before competitors become too strong. The company is taking "a very big risk," as Leo Gebbie, an analyst at CCS Insights, explains. After all, search is by far Google's most important product, and the US is its largest market. In the past, even minor changes to the algorithm have sometimes had serious consequences.

Google Ads is planning a massive integration of artificial intelligence for 2025, which will initiate a transformation in search marketing that the company says will be greater than the mobile revolution. Brendon Kraham, Vice President of Global Search Ads and Commerce, describes this development as a “bigger shift than the mobile revolution.” This suggests further fundamental changes that will affect digital marketing and website visibility.

Impact on the internet ecosystem and the diversity of information

The concentration of information power at Google and the favoring of large platforms like YouTube, Wikipedia, and Reddit have far-reaching consequences for diversity on the internet. When key channels of visibility suddenly disappear, entire business models are thrown into disarray. This development threatens not only small publishers but the entire ecosystem of the open web.

Those who produce high-quality content must not be permanently disadvantaged compared to AI-generated aggregates; otherwise, the open web will lose its pluralistic core. Furthermore, the fundamental chicken-and-egg question arises: if no one generates content anymore, what content will Google display in its AI Overviews? AI systems depend on human-created content, but at the same time, their implementation destroys the incentives for creating such content.

Georg Zöller from the Centre for AI Leadership warns of the long-term consequences: “The foundation of the internet is being destroyed.” The vision of an open, decentralized internet, where diverse voices and perspectives can be heard, is giving way to an increasingly centralized structure in which a few large platforms control the distribution of information.

A turning point in digital journalism

The demise of MIXED.de marks a turning point in digital journalism and highlights the dramatic consequences of Google's AI revolution for the internet ecosystem. The search engine's transformation from an intermediary to a direct provider of answers threatens the very existence of independent online magazines and fundamentally changes how information is found and consumed online.

The figures speak for themselves: traffic drops of 70 to 90 percent for small publishers, the closure of long-established magazines like MIXED, and the increasing concentration of visibility on large platforms. This development is not only a technological but also a societal problem, as it threatens the diversity of information and pluralistic discourse on the internet.

For the future of digital journalism, this means that new business models and distribution channels must be found that are less dependent on Google's algorithmic decisions. The acquisition of MIXED authors by heise online demonstrates one possible path: integration into larger, already established media organizations. At the same time, regulatory approaches must be discussed to limit the market power of tech giants like Google and create fair competitive conditions for small and independent publishers.

The story of MIXED.de is therefore more than just the closure of a VR magazine – it is a symptom of a fundamental transformation of the internet, the effects of which extend far beyond digital journalism and will permanently change the way we find and consume information.

From local to global: SMEs conquer the global market with clever strategies - Image: Xpert.Digital

At a time when a company's digital presence determines its success, the challenge is how to make this presence authentic, individual and far-reaching. Xpert.Digital offers an innovative solution that positions itself as an intersection between an industry hub, a blog and a brand ambassador. It combines the advantages of communication and sales channels in a single platform and enables publication in 18 different languages. The cooperation with partner portals and the possibility of publishing articles on Google News and a press distribution list with around 8,000 journalists and readers maximize the reach and visibility of the content. This represents an essential factor in external sales & marketing (SMarketing).

More about it here:

• Authentic. Individually. Global: The Xpert.Digital strategy for your company

MIXED.de, the largest German-language online magazine for virtual reality and augmented reality, will cease publication on June 1, 2025, after ten years. During this time, more than 17,000 German articles and, since the end of 2021, over 5,000 English articles were published, forming an extensive archive.

Main reasons for the task

• Google search algorithm changes: Profound changes over the past two years have severely hampered the visibility and economic viability of small magazines like MIXED. A core update led to a virtually overnight traffic drop of approximately 90% for the English site. Later, the German site was also affected.
• Increasing competition: The battle for reader attention has intensified (other blogs, YouTubers, general entertainment offerings).
• Upcoming AI transformation: AI is expected to further intensify competition.
• Stagnant interest in VR/AR: Public interest in the core topics has not grown strongly enough to offset the downward trend.
• Economic reality: MIXED was never very lucrative and thrived on the passion of its authors. Revenue from a few hundred Plus subscribers wasn't enough to cover costs. It was heavily reliant on Google advertising revenue.
• Changing media usage behavior: Younger generations prefer video and audio content to text.

Internal consequences of the decline

• Psychological stress for the authors.
• Unpredictable traffic.
• Resource scarcity led to a stronger focus on click potential, which harmed quality and breadth of topics and triggered a vicious cycle.

Suitable for:

• The future of search: Why SEO is no longer enough

Brief analysis

• The case of MIXED.de is symptomatic of the challenges that specialized, independent online media face today:
• Dependence on gatekeepers: The extreme dependence on Google (both for search traffic and advertising revenue) makes small publishers very vulnerable to algorithm changes. A single "core update" decision at Google can threaten their existence.
• Monetization difficulties: It is extremely difficult to run niche journalism profitably. Even with a loyal readership, voluntary subscription models are often insufficient to cover costs when reach declines due to external factors.
• Competitive pressure: The attention economy is brutal. Specialized content not only competes with direct competitors, but with the entire internet.
• AI as a new challenge: The concern that AI-generated content and AI-powered search results (such as Google's AI Overviews) will further reduce traffic for publishers is real and is explicitly mentioned here as one of the reasons for abandoning the platform. MIXED.de is described in the title as the "first prominent victim" of this development.
• Market cycles and hype: MIXED benefited from the Quest 2 boom and the Metaverse hype. When this hype subsided and general interest in VR/AR didn't grow quickly enough to offset the other negative factors, the situation became critical.
• The closure of MIXED.de is a loss for German-language reporting on immersive technologies. It underscores the need for media outlets to develop diversified revenue streams and traffic generation strategies in order to become less dependent on individual platforms – an immense challenge.

☑️ SME support in strategy, consulting, planning and implementation

☑️ Creation or realignment of the AI ​​strategy

☑️ Pioneer Business Development

Konrad Wolfenstein

I would be happy to serve as your personal advisor.

You can contact me by filling out the contact form below or simply call me on +49 7348 4088 965 (Munich) .

I'm looking forward to our joint project.

Xpert.Digital is a hub for industry with a focus on digitalization, mechanical engineering, logistics/intralogistics and photovoltaics.

With our 360° business development solution, we support well-known companies from new business to after sales.

Market intelligence, smarketing, marketing automation, content development, PR, mail campaigns, personalized social media and lead nurturing are part of our digital tools.

You can find out more at: www.xpert.digital - www.xpert.solar - www.xpert.plus