Apprenticeship or university studies: A myth that a career is only possible through university? Decision-making processes, opportunities, and career prospects

Extreme shortage of skilled workers: In these sectors, training is more valuable than a master's degree

After graduating from school, countless young people face one of the most important decisions of their lives: Should they pursue university or a practical vocational training program? For a long time, a degree was considered the gold standard for a successful career. But does this myth still hold in a world of work desperately seeking skilled workers and where practical skills often count more than a theoretical degree? This question is no longer just relevant for graduates – even later in professional life, the choice between academic theory and practical experience repeatedly comes into focus.

This article explores when an apprenticeship can be not only an equally valid, but even the wiser alternative. We examine which personality types are ideal for direct entry into the workforce, which industries—from skilled trades to IT to healthcare—offer tremendous opportunities, and why even the CEO of a global tech company clearly recommends an apprenticeship as an electrician. Find out which arguments are crucial for your personal path and how you can make an informed decision about your professional future that aligns with your strengths, goals, and the demands of tomorrow.

Suitable for:

• Education offensive for more AI competence in Germany – “We don’t have a problem with skilled workers, we have a problem with training!”

Not up for university? 5 reasons why an apprenticeship can put your career on the fast track

Which path leads to professional success – traditional vocational training or a university degree? Are there life situations, industries, or personality traits in which a university education is clearly preferable? What does professional success actually mean, and how can young people make decisions that suit their personality and the demands of the future job market? What prospects does so-called dual training offer, especially in light of digitalization, globalization, and technological innovations? And what answers does the CEO of one of the world's leading technology companies give to the question of who will be most urgently needed in the future?

These and many related questions are being asked by countless young people immediately after graduating from school, as well as by an increasing number of adults during their professional lives. It is worthwhile to examine in detail the advantages and disadvantages of both paths, structural trends in the labor market, and the demands of modern careers, and to compare them.

When is it better to choose an apprenticeship instead of starting a course of study?

What are the reasons for starting an apprenticeship?

If you ask yourself when an apprenticeship is equivalent to or even better than a university degree, you'll come across several compelling arguments. Starting a vocational training program can be sensible, forward-looking, or even more lucrative for various reasons.

Which situations make training particularly attractive?

An apprenticeship is particularly advantageous for those seeking a very specific, highly practice-oriented career where concrete tools, knowledge acquired directly on the job, and routine work are paramount. These include occupations such as electricians, plant mechanics, automotive mechatronics engineers, carpenters, IT specialists, and healthcare and nursing assistants – areas where the demand for trained workers is currently high or even critical. Furthermore, apprenticeships today can be extremely complex and demanding due to additional qualifications and further training leading to master craftsmen or technicians.

Another advantage: Most apprenticeships are organized as a dual program, combining practical experience in a company with academic knowledge transfer. Those seeking a lot of practical experience and personal responsibility early on and wanting to enter the world of work directly are in the right place.

How does starting a career differ between university studies and training?

Those who choose an apprenticeship gain professional experience from day one and earn a monthly income. In contrast, students often spend several years in the classroom and are usually required to complete internships alongside their studies, often with little or no pay. After completing their apprenticeship, graduates are generally immediately employable and valued as skilled workers.

Are there areas in which traditional academic qualifications provide little added value?

Yes – especially in industries characterized by rapid innovation cycles, high levels of specialization, or a shortage of skilled workers. In many skilled trades and technical professions, concrete experience and skills often count more than an academic degree. Furthermore, in some areas such as IT, the event industry, creative professions, or specialized niche providers, there are fields of work for which no standard degree programs exist – but instead, there are customized training models, trainee programs, or career change paths.

Suitable for:

• Reform of mini-job regulations as an economic engine: A new strategy for Germany's labor market

Can training be the starting point for self-employment?

How does training promote steps towards self-employment?

Why can a vocational or technical training provide better conditions for self-employment than a university degree?

Those who complete a thorough training in a practical profession acquire concrete skills that are directly marketable. This applies to professions such as electricians, plumbers, metal workers, carpenters, bakers, hairdressers, or mechanics. Those who want to start a business that provides goods and services, repair services, or skilled trades primarily need professional qualifications, a master craftsman's or technical degree, and a network within the industry. Academic theory, on the other hand, is less frequently required.

In addition, the barriers to entry into self-employment in the skilled trades are often lower and involve less bureaucracy than, for example, in engineering, law, or medical professions, where a university degree, license to practice, or membership in a chamber of commerce are required. Many successful medium-sized businesses were and are run by skilled skilled tradespeople. The step into self-employment is also facilitated by support programs, start-up seminars, and regional networks.

Are there differences in specializations and career access?

In young, dynamic industries or completely new fields of activity, an apprenticeship can certainly offer better access. In the areas of renewable energies, automation, smart home technology, or the installation and maintenance of infrastructure (e.g., solar systems, heat pumps, fiber optic networks, etc.), specialized training courses are increasingly being offered that traditional degree programs cannot even cover. What counts here is rapid, practical learning and participation in real-world projects.

A university degree can be advantageous when setting up your own business if business knowledge, strategic expertise, or scientific know-how are required. In practice, however, business skills are also taught in many master craftsman or technician training programs.

What is the current economic demand like?

Growing demand for skilled workers in the skilled trades

The changing world of work is leading to a renaissance of dual training. The skilled trades sector, in particular, is currently experiencing a noticeable shortage of skilled workers and is dependent on targeted support for young talent. Market experts, politicians, and even international technology leaders are increasingly emphasizing the importance of these professions.

What statements do key economic actors such as the Nvidia CEO make about the development of the labor markets and the need for skilled workers?

In a widely read statement, Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang emphasized that demand for young skilled workers in the trades, especially electricians and plumbers, will increase rapidly. The expansion and maintenance of data centers, which are increasingly part of society's digital infrastructure, also require skilled professionals with technical and technical expertise. Huang said the modern world of work needs "hundreds of thousands of electricians and plumbers" – a forecast supported by developments in the energy transition, broadband expansion, and the digitalization of the economy.

His recommendation is aimed primarily at Generation Z: Young people should be aware that not only academic careers offer bright future prospects. "Real-world," skilled trades and technical professions form the backbone of every modern economy and, especially now, offer enormous opportunities for professional self-realization.

Training paths in the light of digital change

The more automation, artificial intelligence, and digitalization change traditional ways of working, the more differentiated the requirements for qualifications and career access become. While some professions are disappearing or undergoing significant transformation, others are emerging: IT security experts, robotics engineers, specialists in building technology, and renewable energies are examples. Many of these can be covered through modern training paths or dual degree programs, without the need for a traditional university degree.

Our EU and Germany expertise in business development, sales and marketing - Image: Xpert.Digital

Industry focus: B2B, digitalization (from AI to XR), mechanical engineering, logistics, renewable energies and industry

More about it here:

• Xpert Business Hub

A topic hub with insights and expertise:

• Knowledge platform on the global and regional economy, innovation and industry-specific trends
• Collection of analyses, impulses and background information from our focus areas
• A place for expertise and information on current developments in business and technology
• Topic hub for companies that want to learn about markets, digitalization and industry innovations

What are the pros and cons of studying vs. training?

Advantages of training

What advantages does vocational training offer over university studies?

The main advantages include:

• Early career entry and financial independence: Trainees receive remuneration from the start, can build professional networks and gain professional experience.
• High demand for qualified specialists: In the skilled trades, in industry, in nursing and healthcare professions, and in many technical fields, the labor market forecast remains stable to rising.
• Practical qualification: The direct combination of learning and working ensures a realistic understanding and increases employability.
• Diverse career opportunities even without a degree: Master craftsman, technician, or business administrator qualifications are highly recognized advanced training courses that open up careers all the way to company management.

Advantages of studying

In which situations is university studies still recommended?

Going to university is particularly useful if:

• Scientific, engineering, medical, legal, or educational careers are desired. A university degree is usually required for these.
• There is interest in broad, general education, theory, and research. Universities offer opportunities for specialization, international mobility (e.g., through semesters abroad), and the development of academic networks.
• Long-term career goals include leadership positions in large corporations, public administration, or in an international context. University degrees are required in many management positions.
• A deeper understanding of complex relationships, analytical thinking and broad methodological skills are required.

The role of dual study programs and alternative educational paths

Numerous hybrid models have emerged between the poles of "traditional training" and "pure study." Dual degree programs or work-based programs combine theory and practice, offering an academic degree and intensive work experience. These paths are particularly popular in technical, business, and IT-related industries.

In addition, there are industry- or company-specific trainee programs, retraining courses and further training opportunities that are increasingly blurring the boundaries between training and studies.

Suitable for:

• Global shortage of skilled workers: skilled workers from abroad? Why the market doesn't cooperate and the arguments are ethically questionable

Which sectors are particularly suitable for training courses?

Current developments in the labor market

In which professional fields are training paths particularly future-proof?

Sectors with high demand for trainees are currently:

• Construction, trades and technical services (electricians, plumbers, heating and air conditioning technicians)
• IT and technical computer science (IT specialists, system administrators, IT support)
• Health and care professions (nurse, medical assistant, emergency paramedic)
• Industry (mechatronics engineers, industrial mechanics, plant operators)
• Logistics and warehousing (warehouse specialist, warehouse logistics specialist)
• Energy sector, especially renewable energies (solar installers, technicians in the field of photovoltaics/wind energy)
• Food industry, hotel and catering industry
• Creative industries (media design, photography, event management)

These areas benefit from demographic change, technological innovations and new legal frameworks (e.g. energy transition, digitalisation of administration, EU climate targets).

Which character type particularly benefits from training?

Are there personality traits that make starting an apprenticeship more advisable than attending university?

Yes, certain character traits and personal preferences are more suited to an apprenticeship than to a degree course.

People who are more receptive to direct training paths are those who:

• Place value on practical work, tangible results and immediate success.
• Appreciate structure and clear processes.
• Want to become independent early and be financially independent.
• Prefer to work in a team and on specific tasks.
• Have little patience or interest in theoretically oriented seminars.

The training path promotes a sense of responsibility, resilience, and team spirit. Those who easily adapt to practical processes, can work routinely on projects, and enjoy taking on responsibility will benefit from more immediate integration into professional life.

Suitable for:

• 90 percent of Indian engineers lack key qualifications

How does career development depend on the chosen path?

Career options after training

Examples of career paths after training include:

• Further qualification through master craftsman schools, technician or business management courses
• Assuming responsibility in management positions
• Self-employment or business takeover
• Participation in national and international competitions (e.g. WorldSkills)

Earning prospects increase with qualifications, experience, and specialization. For example, those who become a master craftsman in a sought-after trade or pursue further training as a technician will find excellent job markets in many regions of Germany.

Career development after graduation

After completing a university degree, you have the following options:

• Scientific careers or activities in research and development
• Leadership and management functions in companies
• Higher service in authorities or public institutions
• Jobs with high academic requirements (e.g. doctors, lawyers, engineers)
• International career options, especially at globally operating companies

A master's degree or doctorate can facilitate access to even more demanding positions. Earning prospects are higher in the long run, although costs (tuition fees, living expenses, and later career entry) must be taken into account.

How do new technologies and social trends change the choice between training and university studies?

Digitalization as an opportunity for apprenticeships

Digitalization means that trained specialists in technical and skilled trades increasingly need to acquire digital skills. Training is growing in line with these demands:

• Modern training regulations integrate digital tools, software training and practical technical problem-solving.
• Crafts are developing into high-tech professions in which automation, sensor technology and data analysis are part of everyday life.
• Vocational schools and companies cooperate with universities to ensure knowledge transfer.

New job profiles such as “mechatronics engineer for renewable energies” or “IT specialist for system integration” are emerging and offer highly specialized future prospects.

Academicization and social change

At the same time, a trend toward academicization has developed in recent decades: Despite high demand for skilled workers, more and more young people are pursuing university studies. The reasons are varied: social prestige, higher earning potential, flexibility in the labor market, international work, and the desire for theoretical education all play a role.

In doing so, other aspects are easily overlooked: the stability, security, and practicality of many vocational training occupations should not be underestimated. In times of economic instability or economic downturns, occupations with solid training often prove to be more resilient to crises and less affected by unemployment.

Are there long-term trends that speak for or against training?

Which long-term developments influence the attractiveness of an apprenticeship?

The key trend factors include:

• Demographic change – Germany is aging, the shortage of skilled workers is increasing, and demand for traditional professions is increasing.
• Energy transition, sustainability, climate protection – the development of new technologies requires qualified personnel.
• Regionally different labor markets – in rural areas, apprenticeships often offer better career opportunities than academic careers.
• Company permeability – many companies specifically promote the further training of skilled workers (even without a degree) and fill management positions internally.
• Influence of global megatrends – globalization, urbanization, digitalization are constantly changing job profiles and at the same time creating new qualification needs.

By taking these factors into consideration, you can decide for yourself which path is most suitable for your career goals.

Equal, but different – ​​training, studies and hybrid paths for modern careers

• Apprenticeships and university studies are equally valid but different paths to a career. The decision should be based on personal interests, skills, career goals, and current labor market developments.
• For many technical, skilled trades, social and health-related activities, training is the better, practice-oriented choice – especially with the goal of quickly gaining a foothold in the profession or becoming self-employed.
• Highly innovative, theory-based or management-oriented activities usually require a university degree.
• New hybrid paths such as dual study programs combine the advantages of both worlds and are becoming increasingly important.
• Suitability of character, motivation for practical work and the desire to quickly assume personal responsibility speak in favor of this training path.
• The working world of the future needs not only engineers, doctors or business economists, but equally well-trained specialists who can handle energy, technology and practical work.
• Leaders emerge from both worlds.

Whatever the choice, lifelong learning, flexibility, and the willingness to continually adapt to market demands remain the most important skills in professional life in the 21st century.

☑️ Our business language is English or German

☑️ NEW: Correspondence in your national language!

Konrad Wolfenstein

I would be happy to serve you and my team as a personal advisor.

You can contact me by filling out the contact form or simply call me on +49 89 89 674 804 (Munich) . My email address is: wolfenstein ∂ xpert.digital

I'm looking forward to our joint project.

☑️ SME support in strategy, consulting, planning and implementation

☑️ Creation or realignment of the digital strategy and digitalization

☑️ Expansion and optimization of international sales processes

☑️ Global & Digital B2B trading platforms

☑️ Pioneer Business Development / Marketing / PR / Trade Fairs

AI & XR 3D Rendering Machine: Fivefold expertise from Xpert.Digital in a comprehensive service package, R&D XR, PR & SEM - Image: Xpert.Digital

Xpert.Digital has in-depth knowledge of various industries. This allows us to develop tailor-made strategies that are tailored precisely to the requirements and challenges of your specific market segment. By continually analyzing market trends and following industry developments, we can act with foresight and offer innovative solutions. Through the combination of experience and knowledge, we generate added value and give our customers a decisive competitive advantage.

More about it here:

• Use the 5x expertise of Xpert.Digital in one package - starting at just €500/month