AI agency Flovision from Munich under criticism: Media critic Thomas Knüwer explained his criticism of the AI ​​influencer Emma in his blog

✍️📊 Thomas Knüwer, a renowned media critic, has summarized his criticism of the AI ​​avatar Emma insightful blog post Anyone who is interested in the challenges of digitalization in the tourism industry and would like to find out more about the mistakes that Knüwer accuses the German National Tourist Board (DZT) will find detailed information there.

The virtual influencer Emma was developed by Flovision , a company led by Florian Hübner, also known as Mr. Tech. Hübner is a well-known personality in the German AI scene and has made a name for himself as an innovator. Despite its expertise, the Emma project met with considerable criticism.

❌📱 When AI marketing fails: Lessons from the Emma case

Last weekend, the GNTB sparked a storm of indignation with its new AI-generated influencer Emma. The strong reactions raise important questions: Why did the project fail and what should marketers consider when working with AI influencers?

📌🧐Criticisms and insights

1. Authenticity as key

One of the biggest challenges for virtual influencers is developing a credible personality and story. Emma was perceived as a generic character with no depth, which undermined her authenticity. In a world where consumers increasingly value real experiences and stories, this is a crucial disadvantage.

2. Target group understanding

The portrayal of Emma as a stereotypical blonde woman with a model figure was heavily criticized. This representation reinforced existing prejudices about Germany and reflected a lack of understanding of the diverse expectations and needs of the target group. A deeper examination of cultural sensitivities could have prevented this.

3. Quality of interaction

Emma's chatbot function was another area of ​​concern. Users reported inadequate or incorrect answers, further undermining the avatar's credibility. For a virtual influencer to be successful, it is crucial that the interaction is not only smooth, but also informative and helpful.

4. Uncanny Valley Effect

Another aspect that marketers need to consider is the so-called uncanny valley effect. This occurs when AI avatars appear almost human, but appear scary due to small inconsistencies. Emma fell exactly into this area, increasing the discomfort of many users.

5. Thorough testing is mandatory

Technical defects such as blurring of the display or unnatural-looking fingers could have been avoided through careful testing. These details may seem small, but they have a big impact on the overall perception of the avatar.

🙌😅 Great reaction from Florian, my respect 😊

Here are a few excerpts from his post:

The technical creator behind the video (yep, that's me! 🙋) has been dismantled and is now revealing everything.

And yes, with some things like hands etc., I definitely didn't get everything out of it. Thank you for your feedback and shame on me! Being optimized!

Now there are over 3,000 comments in total. I studied every single one! They just haven't solved these challenges for me yet.

But we definitely want to get better with you! I invite you:

Show me how we can better use AI tools to improve video quality! Send me your consistent AI videos in different positions (email in video). I'm looking forward to it, want to & still have so much to learn!

Find out more here on LinkedIn:

• https://www.linkedin.com/posts/florian-huebner_alwayskeeplearning-activity-7254928450132594688-Q4CQ

🔍💡 The role of AI in modern marketing

The Emma case clearly shows the challenges and risks associated with the use of AI in marketing. Virtual influencers can be an innovative way to spread brand messages and reach new audiences. They offer flexibility and control over the brand image and can be active 24/7.

However, their use requires a deep understanding of both technical aspects and human psychology. The balance between technology and humanity must be carefully maintained to be successful.

🌟🚀 Future prospects for virtual influencers

Despite the setbacks, there are promising prospects for the use of virtual influencers:

personalization

As technology advances, virtual influencers can provide increasingly personalized experiences tailored to individual preferences and needs.

Diversity and inclusion

Companies have the opportunity to create more diverse avatars that represent different cultures and identities.

Interactive experiences

By using augmented reality (AR) and virtual reality (VR), virtual influencers can create immersive experiences that go far beyond traditional media.

Data-driven decisions

Virtual influencers can collect valuable data to continually optimize and adjust marketing strategies.

📈🔧 Valuable lesson for marketers worldwide

The Emma case serves as a valuable lesson for marketers worldwide. While AI technologies offer exciting possibilities, their successful use requires careful planning and implementation. Authenticity, understanding of the target group and technical excellence are crucial for the success of virtual influencers.

In an ever-changing digital landscape, companies must be willing to learn from mistakes and continually adapt. This is the only way they can exploit the full potential of AI in marketing and build sustainable relationships with their target groups.

Suitable for:

• What do I have to consider with AI marketing? Important aspects and strategies – authenticity and personality as indispensable elements

AI & XR 3D Rendering Machine: Fivefold expertise from Xpert.Digital in a comprehensive service package, R&D XR, PR & SEM - Image: Xpert.Digital

Xpert.Digital has in-depth knowledge of various industries. This allows us to develop tailor-made strategies that are tailored precisely to the requirements and challenges of your specific market segment. By continually analyzing market trends and following industry developments, we can act with foresight and offer innovative solutions. Through the combination of experience and knowledge, we generate added value and give our customers a decisive competitive advantage.

More about it here:

• Use the 5x expertise of Xpert.Digital in one package - starting at just €500/month

GNTB launches AI influencer for travel destination Germany – Image: GNTB/Flovision

🌍 The introduction of AI into the marketing world has been hailed as a major step forward for years. By using artificial intelligence (AI), companies hope not only to increase efficiency, but also to create personalized experiences and address new target groups. But the use of AI does not always go smoothly, as the example of the German National Tourist Board (GNTB) shows, which recently introduced an AI-generated influencer named Emma. What was intended to be an innovative campaign ended in a shitstorm. But what exactly went wrong, and what lessons can marketers learn from this incident?

💬 The Emma Controversy: An Analysis

Emma, ​​the GNTB's virtual influencer, was supposed to revolutionize the tourism industry in Germany and particularly appeal to younger, digitally savvy target groups. It was developed by the Flowvision agency, which is led by the German AI influencer Florian Hübner. Hübner, known under the pseudonym “Mr. Tech,” is an expert in the field of artificial intelligence and digital innovation. Nevertheless, the introduction of Emma was anything but smooth.

Last weekend, the introduction of Emma sparked a massive shitstorm on social media. Critics such as media expert Thomas Knüwer dissected Emma and the campaign behind it in their blog and shed light on why this marketing measure failed so catastrophically. Knüwer's analysis reveals deeper problems that not only affect Emma as an AI product, but also reveal fundamental deficiencies in the digitalization of the tourism industry.

🔍 The errors in detail

1. Authenticity and credibility: A must for every influencer

One of the biggest problems that came up with Emma was her lack of authenticity. Virtual influencers are not new phenomena. In countries like Japan and the USA, there have been successful examples that have gained millions of followers for years. The key to their success lies in a well-thought-out, credible personality. The character must have its own story, a clear character and a comprehensible motivation in order to resonate with people.

Emma, ​​on the other hand, seemed one-dimensional and superficial. Their presence on social media was limited to standardized answers that often had little to do with the actual needs of the target group. Additionally, her personality and appearance seemed like a stereotypical representation of a blonde woman with a model figure - an image that is both outdated and cliched. Many users expressed criticism that Emma reinforced prejudices about Germany and its tourism industry rather than showing new and innovative ways to discover the country.

2. Understanding the target group: Who is the target group?

Another point of criticism that Knüwer and many other observers highlighted was the lack of understanding of the actual target group. The GNTB created Emma to particularly appeal to younger, digitally savvy people, but her stereotypical appearance and one-dimensional communication spoke against this goal. The social media-heavy generations value diversity, authenticity and deep dialogue with the personalities they follow.

Emma, ​​on the other hand, offered no real points of contact. Their answers were often superficial or even inaccurate, and communication seemed more like a one-way street than allowing real interactions and conversations with the target group.

3. Technical deficiencies: When the uncanny valley strikes

Another serious error was of a technical nature. The term “Uncanny Valley” describes the phenomenon that human-like figures or avatars are perceived as uncanny if they look almost, but not quite, like humans. This is exactly where Emma fell. Her animations and appearance weren't precise enough to be considered realistic, but neither were they stylized enough to be accepted as a purely virtual character. The blurring of her movements and the lack of details, such as her hands, made her seem more scary than appealing to many users.

Technical flaws like these could have been avoided with thorough testing and more attention to detail. But in the rush to bring the project to market, apparently not enough time was invested in this phase.

4. The chatbot as a weak point: Poor interaction scares users away

Another point that contributed to the negative response was Emma's poor chatbot function. Virtual influencers should not only present content, but also be able to interact with their followers. However, Emma's chatbot often provided incorrect or inadequate answers, further undermining her credibility. At a time when users expect personalized and quick responses, this is a serious mistake.

It wasn't enough to simply place Emma on platforms and provide her with standard answers. People today expect tailored communication that addresses their individual questions and needs. But this is exactly where Emma failed. Their chatbot was unable to meaningfully respond to more complex questions and often gave evasive or completely incorrect answers. This led to many users not taking it seriously and considering the entire campaign a failure.

📚 Lessons for marketers: What can we learn from the Emma case?

The Emma case clearly shows how important it is to pay attention to various factors when developing AI influencers to ensure a successful campaign. Here are the key lessons marketers can learn from this incident:

1. Thorough audience understanding is essential

Before starting an AI-supported campaign, it must be clear who the target group is and how they can be reached. It's not enough to rely on stereotypes or follow superficial trends. Rather, the needs, interests and values ​​of the target group must be understood and integrated into the development of the AI ​​persona. Diversity, authenticity and clear storytelling are crucial to gaining trust and sympathy.

2. Technical perfection is mandatory

The Uncanny Valley phenomenon shows that half-finished products in the field of virtual influencers often backfire. Only a technically sophisticated and visually appealing figure can find the necessary acceptance among users. This includes paying attention to every detail, be it facial expressions, movements or interaction options.

3. Interaction is key

Virtual influencers thrive on interaction with their community. A bad chatbot that responds inadequately or incorrectly to user queries massively damages credibility. Here it is important to invest in high-quality chatbots based on artificial intelligence that not only answer simple questions, but can also respond to more complex interactions.

4. Thorough testing before launch

Before an AI campaign goes live, extensive testing must be carried out. This not only affects the technical side, but also the target group's reactions to the figure. Test groups, pilot projects and feedback loops should be used to identify and correct any weak points at an early stage.

⚡ Virtual influencers can undoubtedly be an asset

The Emma case clearly shows how quickly an AI-supported marketing campaign can fail if fundamental aspects such as authenticity, understanding of the target group and technical perfection are neglected. Virtual influencers can undoubtedly be an enrichment for modern marketing, but success depends on the quality of their implementation. Marketers should therefore learn lessons from the Emma shitstorm and ensure that their AI projects are thoroughly thought through, tested and tailored to the needs of the target group right from the start.

📣 Similar topics

• 🤖 The failed appearance of AI influencer Emma
• 🚨 Shitstorm: What Emma did wrong
• ⚠️ Authenticity: Why Emma wasn't convincing
• 🥽 Uncanny Valley: When AI becomes scary
• 📉 Target group understanding: Who should be reached?
• 💬 Chatbot issues: Poor interaction
• 🔄 Technical perfection: What was missing from Emma?
• 🗣️ Interaction: The key to success
• 💡 Lessons from the Emma debacle
• 🎯 Targeted campaign planning: What marketers should consider

#️⃣ Hashtags: #AIMarketing #VirtualInfluencers #DigitalFailure #Authenticity #TechnicalPerfection

☑️ Industry expert, here with his own Xpert.Digital industry hub with over 2,500 specialist articles

Konrad Wolfenstein

I would be happy to serve as your personal advisor.

You can contact me by filling out the contact form below or simply call me on +49 89 89 674 804 (Munich) .

I'm looking forward to our joint project.

Xpert.Digital is a hub for industry with a focus on digitalization, mechanical engineering, logistics/intralogistics and photovoltaics.

With our 360° business development solution, we support well-known companies from new business to after sales.

Market intelligence, smarketing, marketing automation, content development, PR, mail campaigns, personalized social media and lead nurturing are part of our digital tools.

You can find out more at: www.xpert.digital - www.xpert.solar - www.xpert.plus