What role does IP protection – i.e. the protection of intellectual property – play in China for foreign investors?

IP protection in China: New opportunities through specialized courts and tougher penalties

The protection situation for intellectual property (IP) in China has developed significantly in recent years. China has made significant progress in strengthening its IP protection framework, including stricter enforcement, increased penalties for infringements and the establishment of specialized IP courts.

IP protection in China plays a crucial role for foreign investors as it presents both risks and opportunities

1. Improved legal framework

In recent years, China has made significant progress in strengthening IP protection. With the introduction of the new Foreign Investment Law (FIL) in 2019, China has taken measures to better protect the rights of foreign investors. This includes preventing forced technology transfers as a condition for investments and increasing civil liability for IP infringements.

2. Enforcement challenges

Despite these advances, enforcing IP rights in China remains a challenge. There continue to be reports of IP theft and the distribution of counterfeit products, which can result in significant financial losses for foreign companies. China's fragmented government structure and differing responsibilities at the central and local levels make uniform enforcement of IP rights difficult.

3. Judicial and regulatory developments

China has set up specialized courts for IP disputes and streamlined legal processes to more efficiently deal with the growing number of cases. These measures aim to increase confidence in China's IP system and encourage foreign investors to assert their rights.

4. Strategic considerations for companies

Given this mixed landscape, foreign companies must develop careful strategies to protect their IP in China. This includes registering patents and trademarks early and setting up protection mechanisms against potential infringement.

Important aspects of IP protection in China

Registration requirement

In China, protection of intellectual property usually only comes about through official registration. Without this registration, third parties can legally use or copy the intellectual property. This applies in particular to trademarks, patents and copyrights.

Legal framework

Protection includes patents, trademarks, copyrights and trade secrets. Patents are administered by the China National Intellectual Property Administration (CNIPA) and include invention patents with a protection period of 20 years, as well as utility models and design patents with a protection period of 10 and 15 years, respectively.

Specialized dishes

There are over 30 specialized IP courts in metropolitan areas such as Beijing, Shanghai and Guangzhou, staffed by judges who are specially trained in IP law. These courts are accepting more cases every year and processing them more efficiently.

Enforcement and challenges

Despite improvements, challenges in enforcing intellectual property rights remain. However, reports of positive enforcement experiences, particularly in trademark infringement cases, are increasing. The Chinese government has a great interest in ensuring effective IP protection, as many patent registrations come from China itself.

International cooperation: China has ratified international agreements such as the Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPs) and is working to align its laws with international standards.

Recommendations for companies

1. Early registration

Companies should register their trademarks and patents as early as possible to secure their rights.

2. Use local expertise

It is strongly recommended to work with a local Chinese lawyer or specialized agency to navigate the complexities of the Chinese IP legal system.

3. Monitoring and Enforcement

Companies should regularly monitor the market for violations and take legal action if necessary.

4. Confidentiality Agreements

Before working with Chinese partners, confidentiality agreements should be signed to protect trade secrets.

It appears that China is making increasing efforts to improve intellectual property protection and encourage foreign investment. However, it remains important for companies to proactively protect their rights and stay abreast of the latest developments in Chinese IP law.

What other measures can investors take to minimize the risks of direct investment in China?

To minimize the risks of direct investment in China, various countries are taking a number of measures:

1. De-risking instead of decoupling

Many Western countries, particularly in the EU, are pursuing a strategy of “de-risking” rather than full “decoupling”. This strategy aims to diversify economic ties with China and reduce dependence on Chinese supply chains without completely cutting off trade ties.

2. Investment screening mechanisms

The European Union has introduced mechanisms to screen foreign direct investment to ensure that investments do not pose a threat to security or public order. These mechanisms allow Member States to exchange information and raise concerns about specific investments.

3. Diversify supply chains

Companies are encouraged to diversify their supply chains to reduce the risk associated with heavy reliance on China. This often involves implementing a “China plus one” strategy, where companies develop alternative production locations outside of China.

4. Risk management and insurance

Companies are using advanced risk management tools and insurance to protect themselves against political and economic uncertainties. These measures help minimize potential losses due to unforeseen events or political unrest.

5. Strengthen local partnerships

Building strong partnerships with local companies in China can help better navigate cultural and regulatory hurdles. Such partnerships provide access to local knowledge and improve the ability to respond to local market conditions.

These measures reflect a broad range of strategies aimed at managing the risks of investing in China while continuing to benefit from the country's economic opportunities.

Suitable for:

• Apart from Germany, other Western countries see significant risks in direct investments in China
• Overview: Top ten foreign direct investments (FDI) in China – risks and opportunities