Economic miracle examples: How some countries conquered their trade deficit - from minus to plus

Examples of countries that have turned a trade deficit into a trade surplus

A trade deficit occurs when a country imports more goods and services than it exports. However, there are numerous examples of countries that have successfully implemented economic policy measures to improve their trade balance and turn it into a trade surplus in the long term. This transformation is often the result of targeted strategies aimed at expanding export capacity, promoting domestic industry and reducing import costs.

Three outstanding examples are analyzed below: the European Union (EU), China and Germany. Each of these examples highlights specific success factors that can serve as a guide for other countries.

European Union (EU): Success through adapting to new circumstances

The European Union (EU) was able to record a trade surplus again in 2023 after almost two years of a trade deficit. This is a remarkable success because the EU as an economic area consists of numerous member states that have different economic conditions and challenges.

Factors of success

1. Increase exports

The EU benefited from a significant increase in its exports in key sectors such as chemicals, engineering, automotive and food and beverages. The demand for quality European products in international markets contributed significantly to improving the trade balance.

2. Decrease in energy imports

The EU was heavily burdened by high energy import costs in 2021 and 2022. In particular, the energy crisis triggered by the Ukraine war led to a trade deficit as gas and oil had to be imported at extremely high prices. However, from 2023 onwards, energy prices fell and the EU increasingly relied on diversified sources of supply such as LNG (liquefied natural gas) from the USA and renewable energies.

3. Energy independence is key

Through massive investments in renewable energies, the EU was able to reduce its dependence on imports of fossil fuels. This helped stabilize the trade balance and create a surplus in the long term.

These developments show how a region can improve its trade balance through targeted adaptation to external crises. At the same time, they underline the importance of a diversified economic strategy.

China: From an isolated economy to a global trading power

China is one of the best-known examples of fundamental economic change. Until the 1970s, the country was largely isolated and suffered from a weak economy with a negative trade balance. But through far-reaching reforms and a consistent opening up to the global economy, China managed to sustainably improve its trade balance.

Important steps in China's transformation

1. Export-oriented industrialization

From the 1980s onwards, China relied on an aggressive export strategy. Production costs were kept low by cheap labor, making Chinese products competitive in world markets.

2. Special economic zones

The introduction of special economic zones like those in Shenzhen attracted foreign investors and promoted the production of export-oriented goods. These measures were crucial to opening up the Chinese economy and strengthening global trade ties.

3. Integration into global trade

By joining the WTO (World Trade Organization) in 2001, China gained access to international markets. This led to explosive growth in exports, particularly in electronics, machinery and consumer goods.

Long-term results:

• In the 1990s, China achieved an average trade surplus of $16 billion per year for the first time.
• Between 2020 and 2022, this surplus increased to an average of $691 billion per year.

China's success is a prime example of how targeted trade and economic policies can move a country from a deficit phase to a dominant position in global trade.

Germany: From reconstruction to an export nation

Germany is another outstanding example of turning a trade deficit into a trade surplus. After World War II, the German economy was in ruins. But through targeted measures and economic strategies, Germany developed into one of the world's leading export nations.

The basics of success

1. Focus on high-quality industrial goods

Germany was an early adopter of exporting high-quality industrial goods. Mechanical engineering, the automotive industry and chemical products became the flagships of the German economy. “Made in Germany” has become a worldwide synonym for reliability and innovation.

2. Long-term planning

Germany laid the foundation for an export-oriented economy as early as the 1950s. By rebuilding industry and making targeted investments in research and development, the country was able to remain internationally competitive.

3. Stability through the EU and the euro

As a founding member of the EU, Germany benefited from a free internal market and a stable currency. The euro made trade within Europe easier and strengthened the competitive position of German products.

Results

• Since 1952, Germany has exported more goods than it has imported every year.
• Between 2015 and 2022, Germany recorded an average trade surplus of $235 billion per year.

This impressive development shows how a country can have a lasting positive influence on its trade balance through a clear economic orientation and a strong export strategy.

Japan

Japan is another example of a country that has successfully turned a trade deficit into a trade surplus. After World War II, the country's focus was on rebuilding its economy. Through investments in education, technology and industrial production, Japan developed into one of the world's leading economies. In the 1960s and 1970s, the country experienced impressive economic growth that became known as the “Japanese Economic Miracle.” Japan focused on exporting electronics, automobiles, and other high-tech products, resulting in significant trade surpluses.

South Korea

South Korea has undergone a remarkable transformation in recent decades. In the 1960s, the country was still characterized by poverty and had a negative trade balance. Through targeted government strategies, investments in education and technology, and the promotion of large companies, the so-called “chaebols,” South Korea was able to fundamentally transform its economy. Today the country is a leading exporter of electronics, vehicles and ships and regularly experiences trade surpluses.

Ireland

Ireland, once known as the “Celtic Tiger,” greatly boosted its economy in the 1990s through low corporate taxes and attracting foreign direct investment. Multinational companies, particularly in the technology and pharmaceutical sectors, have established production facilities and European headquarters in Ireland. This led to a significant increase in exports and thus to trade surpluses.

Sweden

Over the course of the 20th century, Sweden transformed from an agrarian society into a highly industrialized nation. By investing in technology, education and social welfare, the country created a stable basis for economic growth. Sweden now exports a wide range of products, including vehicles, machinery, paper and pharmaceuticals, and as a result regularly experiences trade surpluses.

Important lessons from the examples

The examples of the EU, China and Germany make it clear that there is no universal solution for improving the trade balance. Rather, success depends on the specific circumstances of a country. However, there are some common factors that can be inferred from these cases:

1. Export promotion

Promoting exports is a central factor. Countries that specifically focus on building competitive industries can establish themselves on global markets in the long term.

2. Diversification of the economy

A broad-based economy that does not rely on just a few industries can better adapt to changes in global markets. The development of various sectors reduces dependence on individual industries and strengthens the overall economy. This also includes the promotion of small and medium-sized companies.

3. Reducing import dependencies

Particularly when it comes to critical resources such as energy, it is crucial to reduce import dependency. Investments in renewable energies or your own raw material sources can avoid high costs in the long term.

4.Industrialization – Industry 4.0 & 5.0

Building a strong industrial base enables the production of competitive goods for the global market. Investments in key industries can increase export ability in the long term.

Suitable for:

• Differences between Industry 4.0 and Industry 5.0

5. Investing in education and technology

A well-educated population and advanced technologies increase productivity and innovation. Research and development is encouraged to create competitive products.

6. Improving competitiveness

Countries can make their products more attractive through quality improvements, innovations and efficiency. Currency devaluations can reduce export prices in the short term.

7. Trade policy

The conclusion of free trade agreements and integration into global trade organizations facilitate access to international markets. Tariffs and trade barriers are reduced to promote trade.

8. Political stability and international cooperation

Political stability and integration into international trading communities such as the WTO or the EU provide important framework conditions for strengthening trade relationships.

Challenges and risks

However, it is important to note that turning a trade deficit into a trade surplus is not without challenges. Countries may encounter international trade conflicts, particularly when trade practices are perceived as unfair. There is also a risk of over-reliance on exports, making the economy vulnerable to global changes in demand. Currency fluctuations and global economic crises can also have negative effects.

Case study: Australia

Australia has traditionally had a trade deficit due to its dependence on imported manufactured goods. However, in recent years the country has benefited from rising raw material prices. Australia was able to achieve temporary trade surpluses by exporting iron ore, coal and liquefied natural gas. This shows how commodity exports can have a positive impact on the trade balance, although this also creates dependencies.

Case study: Brazil

Brazil experienced an improvement in its trade balance in the 2000s through the export of agricultural products, raw materials and energy. By investing in these sectors and opening up new markets, the country has been able to increase its exports. However, Brazil's economy is vulnerable to fluctuations in commodity prices, highlighting the need for a diversified economy.

Converting a trade deficit into a trade surplus

Transforming a trade deficit into a trade surplus is a complex challenge that can be overcome through targeted economic policies and a long-term vision. The examples of the EU, China and Germany impressively show that even countries with large deficits can become global economic success stories with the right strategy. It is not just short-term measures that are crucial, but rather a sustainable approach that takes into account the specific strengths and weaknesses of a country.

Suitable for:

• Globalization rethought: US experts asked – focus on expansion in the US market – production in the USA?
• The US Trade Deficit: A Challenge for the Global Economy