High-bay warehouses – Site decisions and planning disputes in warehouse projects: A field of tension – Image: Xpert.Digital
Caught in the middle: Warehouse locations between efficiency and sustainability
High-bay warehouses – site decisions and planning disputes in warehouse projects: A tension between economic interests and local acceptance
Choosing a suitable location for warehouses and logistics centers is a crucial factor for a company's success, but it increasingly leads to complex negotiation processes between economic interests and local concerns. In an era where efficiency and sustainability are equally essential, companies and municipalities face the challenge of implementing warehouse projects that are both economically viable and socially acceptable. The choice of location not only influences structural aspects but also has far-reaching strategic implications that can determine a company's success or failure.
Suitable for:
Decision factors in the location selection for logistics centers
Determining the optimal storage location is based on a multitude of factors that must be carefully analyzed and weighed. Four fundamental factors emerge: production, demand, costs, and competition. For the most realistic analysis possible, both economic and commercial aspects are evaluated for each of these factors. Product characteristics play a central role, as they significantly influence the type of storage required. Durability, dimensional stability, and handling must be considered. Short delivery routes are crucial, especially for products with a short shelf life, while high-value goods may require special security measures.
Costs represent another critical factor. These include not only infrastructure costs for land, buildings, and equipment, but also personnel, transportation, and handling costs, as well as ancillary costs for outsourced services and insurance. A key objective is to minimize transportation efforts while considering costs in order to maximize warehouse efficiency. Customer demand also significantly influences site selection. Here, the number and location of customers, the volume and frequency of orders, and the importance of proximity and delivery speed play a crucial role.
Last but not least, the competition must also be included in the analysis. The locations, efficiency, and services of competitors can provide important insights for one's own positioning. All these factors together form a complex network that companies must carefully consider in order to make successful long-term location decisions.
High-bay warehouses present a particular challenge in site planning
High-bay warehouses represent a special category of storage facilities with specific challenges. By definition, they are warehouses with racks reaching a height of 7.5 meters or more, with the maximum height currently around 50 meters. These facilities are characterized by high space utilization but require significant investment and are usually fully electronically managed with a warehouse management system. The sheer size of these structures makes them major construction projects that can significantly alter the landscape.
High-bay warehouses, particularly those built using silo construction where the racking serves as the load-bearing substructure for the roof and facade, offer economic advantages but also present unique planning and implementation challenges. Their benefits include rapid and simple construction, cost savings compared to conventional warehouses, and the ability to store goods at great heights. However, planning such facilities requires a comprehensive structural analysis that considers factors such as loads, external influences on the structure, and applicable regulations.
The size and visibility of high-bay warehouses often lead to controversy with the local population. A vivid example is the case of a planned 30-meter-high high-bay warehouse by the Kühne company in Herongen. After the local council initially rejected the construction in the summer, the project was later approved under certain conditions, including holding a public information event and involving an independent expert advisory board to assess its compatibility with the village's character. This case illustrates the dynamics of the negotiation processes between economic interests and local concerns.
Conflicts between economic interests and local acceptance
The construction of warehouses and logistics centers regularly leads to tensions between companies and local residents. The reasons for such conflicts are manifold and range from aesthetic concerns and worries about increased traffic to fears of environmental pollution. In Ladenburg, for example, a new logistics center in the Altwasser industrial park caused considerable uncertainty among residents, who apparently felt they had not been adequately informed beforehand. This lack of transparency and communication is a recurring pattern in the emergence of conflicts surrounding warehouse projects.
The situation becomes particularly critical when hazardous materials storage facilities are involved, as the case in Ladenburg also demonstrates. Here, the concerns of local residents were not merely aesthetic but concerned concrete safety risks. This illustrates that the type of goods stored can have a significant impact on the acceptance of a project. Similar dynamics can be observed with repositories for problematic materials, as the protracted debates surrounding nuclear waste repositories show. Although this is a special case, parallels can be drawn to the local opposition to storage projects in general.
The role of politics in such conflicts is complex. On the one hand, political decision-makers must consider economic interests and jobs; on the other hand, they are under pressure from the local population. A vivid example is the case of the Höffner company, which surprisingly abandoned its plans for a high-bay warehouse after intense pressure from citizens and the public. The politicians were relieved, as they were spared a difficult decision that would have required weighing economic benefits (a €60 million investment and 150 new jobs) against the concerns of the citizens.
Suitable for:
Sustainability aspects as a new dimension in warehouse planning
The increasing importance of sustainability in society is also reflected in warehouse planning. The term "green logistics" encompasses sustainable strategies and measures aimed at reducing the environmental impact of logistical activities. This includes the design of processes, structures, and systems for the transport, distribution, and storage of goods. While the traditional approach to logistics often left considerable room for compromise regarding ecological sustainability, modern concepts strive to achieve an economic and ecological balance.
Sustainable warehouse planning refers to optimizing warehouse processes to use resources efficiently and minimize environmental impact. This includes measures such as using renewable energy, implementing automated systems to increase efficiency, and reducing CO2 emissions. Specific practices for a sustainable warehouse include maximizing energy efficiency through the use of natural light and energy-saving lighting, employing automated storage systems that produce fewer emissions, and implementing sustainable climate control.
Integrating sustainability aspects into warehouse planning can help increase the acceptance of projects among the local population. If companies can credibly demonstrate that they take environmental concerns seriously and are actively working to reduce their ecological footprint, this can alleviate reservations. Furthermore, it aligns with the growing societal awareness of environmental issues, which is also reflected in political demands for environmentally friendly behavior.
Participatory processes and conflict resolution strategies
To minimize conflicts in the planning of warehouse projects, participatory approaches are becoming increasingly important. Early involvement of the affected population can help address concerns and develop solutions that are acceptable to all parties. The case of the high-bay warehouse in Herongen demonstrates the importance of transparent communication and citizen participation: A public information event for all Herongen residents was requested, as well as an assessment from an independent expert advisory board regarding the project's compatibility with the village's character.
The development of conflicts in mixed-use neighborhoods allows for inferences to be drawn about conflicts in storage projects. Conflicts typically go through various phases and can involve both risks and opportunities. Constructive conflict resolution requires both formal instruments, such as legal frameworks and official procedures, and informal approaches, such as mediation and dialogue. In this context, it is important to understand who is in conflict with whom, what is disputed, and how the conflict manifests itself.
Politics faces the challenge of mediating between diverse interests and finding viable compromises. In doing so, it must consider economic, social, and environmental aspects. Long-term and systemic environmental problems pose a particular challenge for policymakers, as ecological requirements often play a subordinate role in concrete decisions. This is not only due to political actors but also to structural causes such as the complexity of environmental policy issues and the unequal access of different interests to political processes.
Future prospects for sustainable and accepted warehouse locations
The future development of warehouse locations will depend significantly on the extent to which economic interests can be reconciled with ecological and social aspects. The integration of modern technologies, such as AI-supported analytics tools for predicting and adjusting inventory levels, can help ensure optimal resource utilization and reduce environmental impact. At the same time, the use of renewable energy in logistics centers enables an improvement in their environmental footprint.
The training of specialists in the transport and logistics sector should increasingly promote environmentally friendly practices and an awareness of sustainable logistics processes. In the long term, this can contribute to a change in the industry culture and increase the acceptance of sustainable solutions. Furthermore, when choosing a location, companies should consider not only traditional factors such as cost and efficiency, but also proximity to transport networks in order to shorten delivery routes and thus reduce CO2 emissions.
The political framework plays a crucial role in shaping sustainable warehousing concepts. Policymakers can promote environmentally friendly behavior through various measures: they can expand or modify government services and infrastructure, design decision-making contexts to facilitate environmentally friendly behavior, and in some cases, issue specific regulations. A balanced combination of incentives, facilitations, and regulations can help companies develop and implement more sustainable warehousing concepts.
Balance between economic, ecological and social interests
Choosing the right location for warehouses and logistics centers remains a complex undertaking that requires balancing various interests. Economic factors such as cost, efficiency, and strategic positioning must be weighed against environmental aspects like resource conservation and emissions reduction, as well as social factors such as local acceptance and participation. The numerous conflicts surrounding planned warehouse projects demonstrate that traditional top-down decision-making processes are increasingly reaching their limits and must be supplemented by participatory approaches.
The increasing importance of sustainability in society also offers opportunities for innovative warehouse concepts that pursue both economic and environmental goals. Companies that adopt sustainable solutions early on and involve the local population in their planning can not only improve their social acceptance but also achieve economic advantages through increased efficiency and enhanced image. Policymakers can support and promote this process by establishing appropriate framework conditions.
Ultimately, a successful site selection for warehouse projects requires a holistic approach that considers all relevant factors and takes into account the needs of all stakeholders. Only in this way can solutions be found that are economically viable, ecologically sustainable, and socially acceptable. The future lies in a balanced approach that considers these different dimensions, enabling the realization of innovative and future-proof warehouse concepts.
Suitable for:
Xpert partner in warehouse planning and construction
We are there for you - advice - planning - implementation - project management
☑️ SME support in strategy, consulting, planning and implementation
☑️ Creation or realignment of the digital strategy and digitalization
☑️ Expansion and optimization of international sales processes
☑️ Global & Digital B2B trading platforms
☑️ Pioneer Business Development
Konrad Wolfenstein
I would be happy to serve as your personal advisor.
You can contact me by filling out the contact form below or simply call me on +49 89 89 674 804 (Munich) .
I'm looking forward to our joint project.
Write to me
Xpert.Digital - Konrad Wolfenstein
Xpert.Digital is a hub for industry with a focus on digitalization, mechanical engineering, logistics/intralogistics and photovoltaics.
With our 360° business development solution, we support well-known companies from new business to after sales.
Market intelligence, smarketing, marketing automation, content development, PR, mail campaigns, personalized social media and lead nurturing are part of our digital tools.
You can find out more at: www.xpert.digital - www.xpert.solar - www.xpert.plus
Keep in touch
