The crisis in the German automotive industry: causes, effects and ways out of the predicament

The German automotive industry, once considered the backbone of the German economy and a symbol of technological innovation and quality, faces one of the greatest challenges in its history. The sector is confronted with a multitude of structural, technological, and geopolitical difficulties that seriously threaten its future viability. This text examines the core causes of the crisis, its impact, and potential solutions to ensure the long-term competitiveness of this key industry.

1. Missed opportunity to transition to electromobility

1.1. Late rethinking and missed opportunities

The German automotive industry clung to traditional combustion engines for a long time. While companies like Tesla and numerous Chinese manufacturers invested in electromobility early on, German brands such as Volkswagen, BMW, and Mercedes-Benz reacted hesitantly. A major reason for this was their strong focus on exporting successful combustion engine models, which led to an underestimation of the need for transformation. "We missed the boat on the shift to electromobility," an industry expert aptly commented recently.

1.2. Weak demand for electric vehicles

Although Germany now has a strong presence in the electric vehicle segment with models like the VW ID.3 and the BMW iX, demand remains below expectations. Reasons for this include the elimination of government purchase incentives, high acquisition costs, and a patchy charging infrastructure. At the same time, Chinese manufacturers like BYD benefit from lower production costs and technologically advanced vehicles that are particularly competitive in Europe.

2. High production costs and declining competitiveness

2.1. Germany as a cost-intensive location

Production costs in Germany are significantly higher than in other countries due to high energy prices and wages. Entry-level models that generate low margins are hardly profitable to manufacture under these conditions. Therefore, German manufacturers concentrate on the premium segment, which makes access to high-growth markets more difficult.

2.2. Low plant utilization

The average capacity utilization of many production facilities is around two-thirds, which impairs plant efficiency and increases fixed costs per vehicle. This problem further exacerbates the cost issue and makes German brands less competitive.

3. Strong international competition

3.1. Dependence on China

For a long time, China was a key growth market for German automakers. Brands like Audi and BMW enjoyed great popularity among the growing Chinese middle class. However, Chinese manufacturers have made significant strides. BYD, Nio, and Geely are increasingly dominating the domestic market and are now also targeting European markets. The market share of German manufacturers in China has declined considerably.

3.2. Technological residues

Another weakness of the German automotive industry is the slow development of digital technologies. Features such as autonomous driving systems or innovative infotainment solutions, which are standard in Tesla or Nio vehicles, are often less sophisticated in German models. Software development, a crucial competitive advantage for the future, has long been neglected by German companies.

4. Economic and geopolitical factors

4.1. Weak economy in Europe

The economic situation in Europe is putting considerable strain on the automotive industry. Consumer restraint and a weak economy are leading many consumers to postpone major purchases such as buying a new car. This is particularly affecting German manufacturers, whose products are high-priced compared to their Asian competitors.

4.2. Trade Policy Risks

International trade relations pose additional risks. In particular, potential US tariffs on German vehicles could severely impact sales in one of Germany's most important export markets. Potential tariffs on Chinese electric cars in Europe could also exacerbate the situation, as such measures could lead to retaliatory tariffs and higher production costs.

5. Structural problems and management errors

5.1. Unclear strategies

Many companies in the German automotive industry operate with unclear and contradictory strategies. Constantly switching back and forth between focusing on combustion engines and electromobility has tied up resources and weakened their innovative capacity.

5.2. Excessive return expectations

Following the high profits during the pandemic, many companies have maintained unrealistic expectations regarding their margins. This pressure to maximize returns has led to excessive cost-cutting measures that jeopardize long-term investments in research and development.

6. Impact of the crisis

The crisis is having far-reaching consequences for the entire industry:

Jobs at risk

Around 130,000 jobs are at risk, as car production has fallen by 23% since its peak, while the number of employees has only decreased by 8%.

Suppliers in crisis

Suppliers are also facing declining orders and rising costs. Many are planning job cuts or restructuring to meet the demands of electromobility.

Loss of significance

Without a fundamental transformation, the German automotive industry risks a long-term loss of importance in the global market.

7. Export dependency and geopolitical challenges

The dependence on export markets like the US and China exacerbates the situation. The US, with a share of around 13%, is the most important market for German passenger car exports, followed by the UK and China. A re-election of Donald Trump and potential punitive tariffs could significantly reduce the profits of Volkswagen, BMW, and Mercedes-Benz. This would further increase the pressure on the industry and could necessitate drastic cutbacks.

8. Ways out of the crisis

To overcome the challenges and regain competitiveness, far-reaching measures are required:

8.1. Focus on electromobility

Electromobility must be consistently expanded. This includes both the development of affordable entry-level models and the establishment of a comprehensive charging infrastructure. Collaborations with technology companies could help strengthen digital skills.

8.2. Efficiency Improvement

Production processes must be optimized to reduce costs. This can be achieved through automation, relocating parts of production abroad, or closing inefficient plants.

8.3. Market Diversification

German automakers should reduce their dependence on individual export markets and tap into new growth regions. Markets in Africa and South America offer potential that has so far remained largely untapped.

8.4. Innovation Promotion

Long-term investments in research and development are essential. German manufacturers need to catch up, particularly in the areas of software, autonomous driving, and sustainable mobility solutions.

Focus on electromobility, digitalization and efficiency improvement

The crisis in the German automotive industry is a complex interplay of missed trends, structural problems, and geopolitical risks. Without radical change, the sector faces a massive loss of relevance. Nevertheless, these challenges also present opportunities: With a clear focus on electromobility, digitalization, and efficiency improvements, German manufacturers can not only secure their position but also tap into new markets and once again assume a leading role as drivers of innovation. However, there is no time to lose.

Suitable for:

• Automobiles: Cars continue to be the most important imported goods in the USA
• China market shares are shrinking: Why Japanese car manufacturers like Honda, Nissan and Toyota are falling behind in China