Operation “Happy Agency Life”: When agencies reinvent themselves every few years and forget who they actually wanted to be

A critical and sarcastic look at the media fortune hunters who take advantage of hype and then disappear again due to the lack of sustainability

Welcome to the glossy circus of self-reinvention: Here, agencies transform every two years from print guru to SEO wizard, then social media shaman, web designer, content whisperer, and now—of course—AI prophet. All with the same conviction, the same PowerPoint presentation, and the same dangerously half-baked knowledge.

While the business cards are still warm from the printer, the next trend color is already being mixed. Employees? Constantly retraining. Customers? Constantly confused. Competence? Constantly a work in progress. And if it goes wrong, no problem – the next hype is just around the corner.

Happy Agency Life: Always flexible, never competent, but with a stylish rebrand every few years.

Happy Agency Life – From print to SEO, to web designer and web developer, to digital agency, and now to AI experts. Everything's easy, everything's chic...

The German agency landscape resembles a chameleon on speed: As soon as a new trend appears on the horizon, the entire industry takes on the corresponding color. What was once touted as indispensable print expertise is now a thing of the past. Business cards are reprinted, websites are redesigned, and suddenly everyone has always been a digital expert, SEO guru, or, more recently, AI revolutionaries. Welcome to the world of media adventurers who embrace every hype while skillfully forgetting one thing: building genuine, sustainable expertise .

The Anatomy of Eternal Change

The media industry has been undergoing a continuous transformation process for decades, which has accelerated dramatically in recent years. What once appeared to be a natural evolution reveals, upon closer inspection, a systematic problem: the inability of many players to develop genuine expertise rather than merely superficially jumping on the bandwagon. The speed with which agencies are repositioning themselves is disproportionate to the time required to build solid competencies.

This problem isn't limited to Germany, but it's particularly pronounced there. Over 200 German agencies are already using generative artificial intelligence, with 33 percent operating as full-service agencies and 30 percent as digital agencies. But how many of them actually possess the depth required for sustainable consulting and implementation? The answer often lies hidden—behind glittering marketing promises and hastily assembled service portfolios.

Metamorphosis as a business model

The transformation from print agency to AI consultancy takes place in predictable phases that follow the principles of the Gartner Hype Cycle. First, there's the technological trigger: A new technology or method is announced. Then, the peak of exaggerated expectations: The media and the market are overflowing with enthusiasm. Agencies sense their opportunity and pounce on the new trend like gold diggers.

The problem isn't the change itself—adaptability is essential for survival. The problem lies in the nature of the change: superficial, opportunistic, and lacking sustainable capability building. Agencies become soldiers of fortune, moving from one gold rush to the next without ever digging deep enough to create sustainable value.

From print nostalgia to AI euphoria

The industry's historic turning points

The journey of the German agency landscape reads like a chronicle of technological change. In the 1990s and early 2000s, traditional advertising agencies dominated with their focus on print media and traditional advertising. Brochures, ads, and posters formed the backbone of the communications industry. Their expertise lay in layout, typography, and the art of conveying messages in limited space.

The first major disruption came with the internet boom. Suddenly, SEO was the magic word, and graphic designers became search engine optimizers overnight. The agencies that managed to pivot in time survived. The others disappeared or eked out a niche existence. What followed was a period of rampant specialization: Web design agencies sprang up like mushrooms, each claiming to offer the best digital solution.

The social media tsunami

With the emergence of social media platforms around 2010, the industry experienced its next transformation. Suddenly, everyone was a social media expert. Facebook marketing, Twitter strategies, and later Instagram campaigns became the new gold standard. Agencies that had struggled to create a simple website just a few years earlier now touted themselves as social media gurus.

The speed of the transformation was breathtaking—and suspicious. True expertise in a field as dynamic as social media requires not only technical understanding, but also a deep understanding of user behavior, community management, and the platforms' constantly changing algorithms. Many agencies, however, offered only superficial solutions: a few posts here, a campaign there, without any strategic depth or sustainable development.

The Mobile Revolution

When smartphones conquered the market, the next metamorphosis followed. Mobile marketing became the new holy grail. Responsive web design, app development, and location-based marketing suddenly appeared on every agency website. Once again, service providers transformed from one specialization to the next seemingly overnight.

The irony is that while agencies increasingly broadened their services, the market simultaneously became more specialized. True expertise increasingly became a differentiator, but many players failed to recognize this trend or deliberately ignored it in favor of the illusion of complete competence.

The Content Marketing Hype

With the realization that content is king, agencies pivoted again. Content marketing became the buzzword of the moment. Storytelling, brand journalism, and influencer marketing dominated pitch presentations. Agencies that had previously primarily designed banners and ads now sold themselves as content strategists and storytellers.

But here, too, the same pattern emerged: Most agencies jumped on the bandwagon without truly understanding the complexity and depth of content marketing. True content marketing requires journalistic skills, industry knowledge, strategic thinking, and the ability to develop long-term narratives. Instead, many agencies produced interchangeable content without a clear strategy or measurable added value.

The current AI revolution

Today we are experiencing the latest transformation: the AI ​​revolution. ChatGPT and other generative AI tools have sparked a new gold rush. Suddenly, everyone is an AI expert, AI marketing specialist, and automation guru. The speed of the transition is, as always, impressive—and worrying.

2025 is being touted as the "Year of AI Agents," and the promises are enormous: automation of routine tasks, personalized campaigns in real time, data-driven decisions, and efficiency improvements beyond anything previously imagined. But how many of the agencies offering AI services today truly possess the depth and understanding of this complex technology?

History repeats itself: superficial adaptation instead of solid competency development. The danger is greater than ever, because AI is not just another tool, but a fundamental technology that requires a deep understanding of data analysis, algorithms, and ethical considerations.

The mechanics of marketing opportunism

The Gartner Hype Cycle as a business basis

The mechanisms behind the perpetual change in the agency landscape follow astonishingly precise patterns. The Gartner Hype Cycle, originally developed as an analytical tool for evaluating technologies, has become an unspoken business principle for many agencies. The five phases—technology trigger, peak of inflated expectations, trough of disappointment, path to enlightenment, and plateau of productivity—are not understood as a warning against jumping to conclusions, but as a roadmap for the next repositioning.

The process is frighteningly mechanical: As soon as a new technology triggers the initial media hype, the major transformation begins. Websites are redesigned, service catalogs are expanded, and employees are trained in crash courses. Within a few weeks, SEO agencies transform into AI consultancies, web designers into UX strategists, and content marketing specialists into data scientists.

Opportunism as a survival strategy

The agencies' opportunistic behavior follows an economic logic that, at first glance, seems entirely understandable. In a fast-moving market, adaptability seems to be the most important survival strategy. Those who jump on new trends too late lose clients to agile competitors. Those who refuse to expand their portfolios are labeled backward.

But this logic leads to a dangerous spiral. Instead of building deep expertise in one area, agencies become generalists without true specialization. They offer everything but aren't particularly good at anything. Clients become test subjects for half-baked solutions, while the agencies themselves lose their own identity.

The illusion of full competence

Particularly problematic is the illusion of complete competence that many agencies cultivate. They portray themselves as experts in everything: print and digital, SEO and social media, content and AI, strategy and implementation. This claim is not only unrealistic but also damaging to the entire industry.

True expertise requires time, focus, and continuous training. An SEO expert who truly understands their craft has spent years studying algorithms, conducting tests, and delving into the ins and outs of search engine optimization. An AI specialist must understand not only the technical aspects but also the ethical implications, the limitations of the technology, and the specific applications in different industries.

The business of ignorance

Many agencies deliberately exploit their clients' ignorance. Since most companies lack the technical expertise to assess the quality of SEO, social media marketing, or AI solutions, agencies can get away with superficial knowledge. They use buzzwords, present impressive statistics, and promise revolutionary results without truly understanding the processes behind them.

This business model works in the short term, but is doomed to failure in the long term. Clients sooner or later notice when the promised results fail to materialize. Reputation suffers, and the agency is forced to switch to the next trend to survive. A vicious cycle develops that harms everyone involved.

The acceleration of change

Modern communication technologies have dramatically increased the speed of trend cycles. What once took years now takes months. Social media ensures the viral spread of new ideas, while the constant availability of information increases the pressure to always be up to date.

This acceleration benefits superficial trend jumpers. They no longer have to invest years in building genuine expertise; instead, they can emerge as experts after just a few weeks of training. There's a real risk that this approach will become the norm, and genuine expertise the exception.

The perfect example of the eternal present

AI agents as the latest savior

The current situation in the German agency landscape perfectly reflects all the problematic mechanisms of marketing opportunism. 2025 is being touted as the "Year of AI Agents," and as if on cue, hundreds of agencies have transformed into AI experts. The speed of this transformation is breathtaking: Agencies that struggled to develop a coherent social media strategy just a few months ago now offer complex AI automation and machine learning as their core competencies.

The promises are as tempting as they are unrealistic. AI is supposed to automate routine tasks, create personalized campaigns in real time, and revolutionize marketing efficiency through data-driven decisions. Over 200 German agencies are already using generative AI tools, but the quality of implementation varies dramatically. While established players like Ippen Digital are developing sophisticated AI agent workflows with human-in-the-loop approaches, many others limit themselves to using ChatGPT for copywriting and sell this as an "AI marketing revolution."

The reality behind the scenes

A look behind the shiny facades of newly minted AI agencies often reveals sobering realities. Many of the AI ​​services offered consist of standard tools like ChatGPT or Canva, which any intern can use after an hour of training. The promised "strategic AI consulting" turns out to be superficial automation of simple tasks, lacking a deeper understanding of the complexity and limitations of the technology.

Particularly problematic is the lack of transparency towards clients. While presentations talk about "proprietary AI algorithms" and "custom machine learning solutions," many agencies simply use standard APIs and ready-made tools. Clients pay premium prices for services they could easily provide themselves with some training.

The happiness paradox of the agency world

Parallel to this superficial boom, a deeper problem in the industry is becoming apparent: the lack of satisfaction among its own employees. The 2024 Agency Happiness Report revealed alarming figures: 54 percent of agency employees regularly consider quitting – significantly more than in other industries. One in two employees is dissatisfied with their job.

These figures are no coincidence, but rather the logical result of an industry that redefines its identity every few years. Employees are constantly pressured to retrain, have to familiarize themselves with ever-new areas, and experience how their hard-earned skills are devalued overnight. The constant uncertainty about which trend will next sweep the industry creates a work environment of constant tension.

Sustainability as the next trend candidate

As AI euphoria reaches its peak, the next big trend is already emerging: sustainability and ESG compliance. The irony is perfect: Sustainability, of all things, is becoming the next superficial hype for an industry that is itself anything but sustainable.

Already, some agencies are positioning themselves as "sustainability experts" and "ESG consultants," even though they themselves follow a business model based on constant change and a throwaway mentality for acquired skills. The contradiction couldn't be greater: Companies that change their entire positioning every few years want to advise others on developing long-term and sustainable strategies.

AI disillusionment is looming

Initial signs indicate that AI euphoria has already passed its peak and is approaching the "trough of disappointment" of the Gartner Hype Cycle. Experts warn against exaggerated expectations and urge more realistic assessments of AI's capabilities. The next stage of AI development would require immense amounts of data and bizarre investments – resources that many of the self-proclaimed AI agencies simply don't have.

When disillusionment sets in, the wheat will be separated from the chaff. Agencies with genuine AI expertise will survive and profit, while the superficial free riders will have to move on to the next trend. The pattern repeats itself, and the victims, as always, are the clients who paid for half-baked solutions and the employees who once again have to be retrained.

Xpert.Digital has in-depth knowledge of various industries. This allows us to develop tailor-made strategies that are tailored precisely to the requirements and challenges of your specific market segment. By continually analyzing market trends and following industry developments, we can act with foresight and offer innovative solutions. Through the combination of experience and knowledge, we generate added value and give our customers a decisive competitive advantage.

More about it here:

• Use the 5x expertise of Xpert.Digital in one package - starting at just €500/month

When the bubble bursts – Return to substance: Authenticity as a future strategy for agencies

Transformation agencies as a beacon of hope

A positive example can be found in the nationwide transformation agencies, which practice a different kind of consulting. These initiatives pursue a holistic approach to digital transformation that goes far beyond superficial trend advice. They offer transparent information about the opportunities and challenges of transforming the world of work and develop individual courses of action.

The approach of transformation agencies is fundamentally different: Instead of selling quick fixes, they focus on education, networking, and long-term support. They act as guides in the complex transformation process, bringing together various stakeholders. Their success is not based on exploiting ignorance, but on building expertise in the companies they advise.

Hybrid marketing as a sustainable approach

Some progressive agencies have recognized that the future lies not in constant reinvention, but in the intelligent combination of tried-and-tested and new methods. Hybrid marketing, which cleverly combines print and digital elements, demonstrates a way to combine traditional skills with modern technologies.

Instead of demonizing the past and focusing exclusively on the latest trends, these agencies use QR codes, personalized landing pages, and cross-media campaigns to combine the best of both worlds. This approach demonstrates maturity and strategic thinking—qualities that have become rare in the hectic agency world.

Specialization as a success factor

The most successful agencies in the coming years will likely be those that have the courage to specialize. Instead of offering everything, they focus on a few areas and develop genuine expertise there. One example is the Vier D digital agency, which has deliberately specialized in the "green sector," combining agricultural expertise with modern marketing.

This specialization allows us to delve deeply into the industry, understand its specific challenges, and develop customized solutions. Clients value this depth significantly more than superficial claims of complete competence. Building industry expertise takes years, but it creates a sustainable competitive advantage.

Transparency as a differentiator

Agencies that openly communicate their limitations and are transparent about their methods are increasingly gaining trust. Instead of advertising with proprietary algorithms and secret knowledge, they explain to their clients exactly which tools they use, what realistic results are, and where the limits of their expertise lie.

This honesty may seem less impressive in the short term than boastful promises, but it creates significantly more stable customer relationships in the long run. Clients who understand what they're buying are more satisfied with the results and develop trust in the consulting agency.

The dark side of permanent change

Greenwashing in sustainability communication

The problem of superficial trend adaptation is nowhere more evident than in the topic of sustainability. While agencies advise their clients on "green marketing," they themselves often practice the exact opposite of sustainable business practices. The 2023 Corporate Climate Responsibility Monitor revealed a sobering truth: Not a single one of the 24 global companies examined has truly fulfilled its climate pledges. Instead of the required 43 percent emissions reduction by 2030, 22 of them are targeting a meager 15 to 21 percent.

This discrepancy between aspiration and reality is also reflected in the agency world. Agencies that offer sustainability consulting today themselves follow a business model based on constant change and the systematic devaluation of acquired skills. The irony couldn't be greater: companies that change their entire positioning every few years are advising others on developing long-term and sustainable strategies.

The problem is exacerbated by the lack of credibility in communication. 66 percent of consumers avoid companies caught engaging in greenwashing. This mechanism is increasingly affecting agencies that only feign their sustainability. Customers are becoming more sensitive to authenticity and more quickly see through superficial positioning.

The devaluation of expertise

Continuous change leads to a systematic devaluation of expertise. Employees who have spent years learning SEO, social media, or content marketing find their skills devalued overnight when the agency switches to the next trend. This dynamic creates a culture of superficiality in which deep expertise is valued less than the ability to adapt quickly.

The consequences are dramatic: True experts are leaving the industry or founding their own specialized companies, while agencies are increasingly left with generalists without in-depth expertise. The quality of advice is declining, customer satisfaction is suffering, and the entire industry is losing its reputation.

Trend surfing as a business model

Particularly problematic is the development of trend surfing into a conscious business model. Instead of building sustainable competencies, some agencies specialize in always being the first to jump on new trends. They invest minimal resources in superficial training and maximize marketing effects through aggressive PR and self-promotion.

This model works in the short term, but is destructive in the long term. It not only harms its own clients, but also poisons the market environment for reputable providers. Clients are becoming increasingly skeptical of all agencies, having had bad experiences with superficial trend-jumpers.

The industry's crisis of confidence

The sum of these developments is leading to a creeping crisis of confidence throughout the agency industry. Clients are becoming more cautious in their selection of service providers and are more critically questioning the skills offered. At the same time, there is a growing willingness to develop services in-house or to rely on specialized freelancers instead of relying on agencies.

This development poses a fundamental threat to the traditional agency model. When clients lose confidence in the competence and stability of agencies, the entire business model is called into question. The industry faces a choice: return to sustainable business practices or further marginalization.

Employee turnover as a system problem

The high level of dissatisfaction among agency employees is not just an HR problem, but a systemic issue that fundamentally impacts the quality of service. With 54 percent of employees regularly considering leaving, this leads to high turnover, loss of knowledge, and unstable customer relationships.

This dynamic becomes particularly problematic when it coincides with the constant shift in agency positioning. Employees who have just been trained in a new skill set leave the company before they have had a chance to develop true expertise. What's left is an agency lacking in-depth know-how that nevertheless sells complex consulting services.

The downward spiral of quality

All of these factors reinforce each other and lead to a downward spiral in quality. Superficial competence leads to poor results, which increases customer dissatisfaction and exacerbates pricing pressure. Lower margins lead to lower investments in continuing education and competence development, which further reinforces superficiality.

This vicious cycle can only be broken through conscious decisions by individual agencies that commit to sustainable competency development and honest communication. The longer the industry waits, the more difficult it will be to regain lost trust.

The future belongs to the authentic

The end of AI euphoria is looming

There are increasing signs that the current AI euphoria has already passed its peak and is approaching the "trough of disappointment" of the Gartner Hype Cycle. Experts warn against exaggerated expectations and emphasize that the next stage of generative AI would require immense amounts of data, absurd amounts of energy, and bizarre investments – resources that most self-proclaimed AI agencies simply don't have.

It's already clear today that many of the highly touted AI solutions fail to deliver the promised revolutionary results. Instead of strategic breakthroughs, untrained AI models often produce irrelevant content, interchangeable visuals, and time-consuming workflows. Disillusionment sets in, and with it the realization that AI is a tool that requires expertise rather than replaces it.

Sustainability as the paradoxical Next Big Thing

Parallel to the AI ​​disillusionment, the next major trend is already emerging: sustainability and ESG compliance. The irony is perfect – sustainability, of all things, is becoming the next superficial hype in an industry that is itself anything but sustainable. ESG criteria are evolving from a marketing hype to a necessary core strategy, but their implementation requires precisely the long-term perspective and authenticity that the agency industry lacks.

Companies are increasingly being pressured by investors, customers, and regulatory requirements to develop genuine sustainability strategies. Superficial green marketing campaigns are no longer sufficient – ​​what's needed are sound ESG strategies based on measurable criteria and designed for the long term. Agencies that only superficially embrace this trend will quickly be exposed.

The major market consolidation is imminent

The convergence of various trends points to an impending market shakeout. AI tools are becoming increasingly commoditized and available to everyone, eliminating the competitive advantage of superficial AI agencies. At the same time, the demands for authenticity and sustainability are increasing, putting agencies without real substance under pressure.

Clients are becoming more demanding and critical. They're quicker to see through superficial positioning and are willing to pay more for real expertise. Agencies that specialize in constant change will find that their adaptability is less valued than the consistency and depth of their competitors.

Specialization as a survival strategy

The future belongs to agencies that have the courage to specialize. Instead of offering everything, they concentrate on a few areas and develop true expertise there. This focus allows them to delve deeply into industries, understand specific challenges, and develop customized solutions.

Examples like the Vier D digital agency, which specializes in the "green industry," or agencies that focus on specific technologies or industries, point the way. Clients value this depth significantly more than superficial claims of complete competence. Building expertise takes years, but it creates a sustainable competitive advantage.

Transparency and honesty as differentiators

Agencies that openly communicate their limitations and are transparent about their methods will gain increasing importance. Instead of advertising with proprietary algorithms and secret knowledge, they explain to their clients exactly which tools they use, what realistic results are, and where the limits of their expertise lie.

This honesty may seem less impressive in the short term than boastful promises, but it creates significantly more stable customer relationships in the long term. The "human-in-the-loop" concept, as practiced by Ippen Digital, exemplifies how technological innovation can be combined with human expertise and ethical responsibility.

Hybrid models as a sustainable approach

The future likely lies not in complete digitalization, but in intelligent hybrid models that combine the best of different worlds. Agencies that can combine traditional skills with modern technologies without losing their identity will be the winners in the coming years.

This development requires a new way of thinking: Instead of chasing trends, it's about identifying constants and connecting them with the possibilities offered by new technologies. Instead of changing your positioning every few years, it's about developing a consistent identity and continuously evolving it.

The end of the fortune hunter era

The return to substance

An analysis of the German agency landscape reveals a fundamental problem: The transformation from competency-based service providers to opportunistic trend-jumpers has weakened the entire industry. What began as a necessary adaptation to changing market conditions has evolved into a destructive pattern of constant reinvention without sustainable competency development.

Media fortune hunters who embrace every hype and forget to build genuine expertise not only damage their own long-term prospects for success but also poison the market environment for reputable providers. The consequences are measurable: 54 percent of agency employees regularly consider quitting, 66 percent of consumers avoid companies caught engaging in greenwashing, and the crisis of trust in the industry continues to deepen.

The path back to credibility

The solution lies not in even faster adaptation cycles or even more superficial trend adaptations, but in a return to fundamental business principles: authenticity, specialization, and sustainable competence building. Agencies must muster the courage to focus, communicate the limits of their expertise, and prioritize long-term client relationships over short-term trend profits.

The impending AI disillusionment will act as a catalyst for this transformation. If the superficial AI promises aren't fulfilled, the wheat will be separated from the chaff. Agencies with genuine technological expertise and a sustainable business model will benefit, while the adventurers will have to move on to the next trend—assuming there is one that rewards their superficial approach.

A paradigm shift is imminent

The signs point to change. Clients are becoming more demanding, employees are less satisfied with unstable work environments, and societal demands for sustainability and authenticity are continually rising. Agencies that ignore this development and continue to rely on opportunistic trend-chasing will find themselves increasingly marginalized.

The paradigm shift from quantity to quality, from superficiality to depth, from conformity to authenticity is inevitable. The only question is whether individual agencies will proactively shape this change or suffer passively. The Happy Agency Life, which assumes a new identity every few years, will become an Unhappy Agency Death when the lack of substance of the business model becomes apparent.

The German agency landscape is at a crossroads. The road back to credibility is rocky and requires foregoing short-term gains in favor of long-term stability. But it is the only way out of self-inflicted irrelevance. The era of media fortune hunters is coming to an end – the era of authentic experts is beginning.

☑️ Our business language is English or German

☑️ NEW: Correspondence in your national language!

 

I would be happy to serve you and my team as a personal advisor.

You can contact me by filling out the contact form or simply call me on +49 89 89 674 804 (Munich) . My email address is: wolfenstein ∂ xpert.digital

I'm looking forward to our joint project.

 

 

☑️ SME support in strategy, consulting, planning and implementation

☑️ Creation or realignment of the digital strategy and digitalization

☑️ Expansion and optimization of international sales processes

☑️ Global & Digital B2B trading platforms

☑️ Pioneer Business Development / Marketing / PR / Trade Fairs

Industry focus: B2B, digitalization (from AI to XR), mechanical engineering, logistics, renewable energies and industry

More about it here:

• Xpert Business Hub

A topic hub with insights and expertise:

• Knowledge platform on the global and regional economy, innovation and industry-specific trends
• Collection of analyses, impulses and background information from our focus areas
• A place for expertise and information on current developments in business and technology
• Topic hub for companies that want to learn about markets, digitalization and industry innovations

AI search changes everything: How this SaaS solution is revolutionizing your B2B rankings forever.

The digital landscape for B2B companies is undergoing rapid change. Driven by artificial intelligence, the rules of online visibility are being rewritten. It has always been a challenge for companies to not only be visible in the digital masses, but also to be relevant to the right decision-makers. Traditional SEO strategies and local presence management (geomarketing) are complex, time-consuming, and often a battle against constantly changing algorithms and intense competition.

But what if there were a solution that not only simplifies this process, but makes it smarter, more predictive, and far more effective? This is where the combination of specialized B2B support with a powerful SaaS (Software as a Service) platform, specifically designed for the needs of SEO and GEO in the age of AI search, comes into play.

This new generation of tools no longer relies solely on manual keyword analysis and backlink strategies. Instead, it leverages artificial intelligence to more precisely understand search intent, automatically optimize local ranking factors, and conduct real-time competitive analysis. The result is a proactive, data-driven strategy that gives B2B companies a decisive advantage: They are not only found, but perceived as the authoritative authority in their niche and location.

Here's the symbiosis of B2B support and AI-powered SaaS technology that is transforming SEO and GEO marketing and how your company can benefit from it to grow sustainably in the digital space.

More about it here:

• B2B Support & Blog for SEO, GEO and AIS – Artificial Intelligence Search
• Forget expensive SEO tools – this alternative dominates with unbeatable B2B features